It is not uncommon for current events to come up as a topic of discussion in therapy sessions. As a result, I have been having several discussions with clients regarding the topic of George Floyd and the current protests. While I recognize that this might not be a topic many clinicians would be comfortable discussing for a number of valid reasons, as a black, female, social worker I choose to engage in these discussions.
I am fortunate to work with a diverse population of clients and as a result I’ve had this discussion using various lenses and perspectives. Below are some of the questions I’ve received and how I choose to answer them.
Q: I am really upset with what happened and really sad; however, I am not a BIPOC. Am I even allowed to be upset? Is this even my fight?
Yes, this is your fight. Yes, you are allowed to be upset. As humans, it is empathy that allows us to understand and share the feelings of others. While you may not have the same lived experience, it is reasonable to understand and share the feelings of sadness, anger, and outrage that are shared across communities at this time.
Q: What can I say to a BIPOC to demonstrate that I understand and not make this about me and my feelings?
Something as simple as “I see it”. Can be really powerful statement. For many BIPOC who have shared their experiences, there has been constant dismissal which comes in the form of:
- “That never happened”.
- “I’ve never been treated that way.”
- “Well, if they just would have…”
These statements invalidate the lived experiences of BIPOC. Everyone just wants to be heard, loved, and respected. Simply saying “I see it. I hear you. I love you.” can be a powerful start. Granted, this won’t change systemic racism. But, it is something.
Q: What can I say to other non-BIPOC/ other POC about the protests?
One of the distinctions I find to be helpful in discussing this topic is that while the narrative of George Floyd and other black people who died in interactions with the police are often centered on racism alone, there deeper ways to view this topic.
- Racism exists. It is endemic to our society. It is well documented historically and continues to play a large part of all of our current systems. It can be seen in housing segregation, public education, public health, etc. If you would like more information about this, you can check out the entire catalogue of NPR Code Switch’s podcasts which discusses these topics at length. (https://www.npr.org/sections/codeswitch/)
- Police officers kill Americans at an alarming rate, especially Black Americans:
Every year, more than a thousand people are killed by a police officer in the United States. And that is many more people than are killed in other countries with similarly advanced economies. For example, last year, someone who lives in the U.S. was almost 60 times as likely to be killed by police as someone in the United Kingdom. And within the U.S., there is also a big disparity. A black American like George Floyd is about three times as likely to be killed by police as a white person. – Cardiff Garcia, NPR The Indicator Podcast (https://www.npr.org/2020/06/03/869176943/police-unions-and-civilian-deaths)
- There is a historical context to the relationship between Black Americans and American Policing. (https://www.npr.org/2020/06/03/869046127/american-police).
- Lack of accountability for previous killings have contributed to the level of frustrations of todays protestors. (https://www.npr.org/2020/05/29/865261916/a-decade-of-watching-black-people-die)
Q: How can we build towards the future if people can’t agree on these events?
One of the things that often occurs when you work with couples is the concept that there are several variations of truths. The concept that two different people can experience the same situation and have different accounts of what occurred. This is especially true when it comes to couples counseling.
Often what feels important is for there to be a shared understanding of what occurred previously, but this is not always feasible. The way memories are stored and remembered is highly predicated on how we felt about an event rather than an autobiographical understanding of what occurred (Think Riley from the Disney Pixar movie Inside Out). We can’t always come to a shared meaning about an historic event. But, we can come to a understanding of where we want to be in the future. We can actively work to build towards the shared future we all want.
I’ve added the links to several podcasts because I feel that they are relatively easy way to gain general knowledge about these very difficult topics.